Exceptional by Design

How to Fix High-Skilled Immigration to Maximize American Interests

By Adam Ozimek, Connor O’Brien, and John Lettieri

High-skilled immigration is America’s not-so-secret weapon, a vital driver of economic growth, innovation, and national strength. Yet today, our system is falling short—failing to prioritize the highest achievers, burdening American businesses with red tape, and leaving broad swathes of the country behind.

This report offers a new way to look at skilled immigration, starting with a fuller understanding of its economic benefits than what skilled immigration advocates and critics have to offer. It debunks common myths about how immigration policy works in practice and rethinks the longstanding assumption that our immigration system should be primarily concerned with filling supposed labor shortages.

Finally, this report proposes a suite of reforms to modernize and expand our skilled immigration system. Its recommendations would build an immigration system that is friendly to job-creating entrepreneurs, boosts critical industries with national security implications, contributes to regional revitalization, and reduces the nation’s deficit. Most importantly, they would improve economic opportunities for American workers and communities.

Read the Report

Resources

Executive Summary

Read the Executive Summary

The Policy Vision

Read the Policy Fact Sheet

Immigration Myths and Reality

Read about Immigration Myths vs Reality

Explore with AI

Do you have questions about our report? We trained a custom ChatGPT bot to answer them. Ask about our proposal and our unique insights into the economics of high-skilled immigration. 

Ask ChatGPT

Debunking Immigration Myths

 Myths about the economic impact of high-skilled immigration are preventing the U.S. immigration system from living up to its potential. EIG partnered with Kyla Scanlon, economics commentator and educator, to produce videos debunking some of the myths that lead both critics and advocates of high-skilled immigration to underestimate its impacts on innovation, entrepreneurship, and local economic growth.

Myth: High-skilled immigrants take jobs from American workers

Reality: High-skilled immigration boosts population growth, business formation, and capital investment — all of which increase demand for more workers.

Watch Now

Myth: Labor market shortages can be addressed by tailored high-skilled immigration policy

Reality: Labor market shortages are ill-defined and impossible to measure. Tailored policy is thus badly suited to deciding which jobs immigrants should do. Let the market decide instead.

Watch Now

Myth: Expanding high-skilled immigration is politically risky

Reality: An overwhelming majority of voters support increasing high-skilled immigration, and bipartisan consensus in favor of high-skilled immigration is as strong as ever.

Watch Now

Analysis

  • Categories: Analysis, Policy

    September 25, 2023

  • Categories: Analysis

    April 2, 2024

  • Categories: Policy, Reports

    May 15, 2024

  • Categories: Analysis

    May 21, 2024

  • Categories: Analysis

    June 4, 2024

  • Categories: Analysis

    June 27, 2024

News

  • National Review

    Categories: In the News

    January 14, 2025

  • Axios

    Categories: In the News

    January 14, 2025